eBay: ‘Rare’ Sherlock Holmes 50p coin listed for £14,000 – should you buy it now?

eBay: 'Rare' Sherlock Holmes 50p coin listed for £14,000 - should you buy it now? 46

eBay has become one of the world’s most popular sites for coin collectors and enthusiasts to find unique pieces to add to their collections. The online auction site lists hundreds of allegedly ‘rare’ coins on a daily basis.

One such piece is the Sherlock Holmes 2019 50p coin, which was recently posted on the site for a shocking £14,000. Branded as ‘rare’ by the current owner, the seller, who goes by the screen name “c.oakes” has uploaded the coin to the online auction site and has suggested a starting bid of £14,000, but is it really worth the eye-watering cost?

Luckily the high asking price seems to be covering any other costs, as the current owner is offering interested buyers the opportunity to purchase the coin without having to worry about postage fees, offering free delivery for the purchase. So at over 2000 times its face value, is the coin as rare as the owner is claiming?

Designed by Stephen Raw, the coin in question is the “Sherlock Holmes 2019 UK 50p Brilliant Uncirculated Coin”, an exciting addition to a coin collection as it is the first time Sherlock Holmes has been featured on a UK coin.

Described as the “perfect gift for fans of Sherlock Holmes and the work of Sir Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle,” the coin is finished to Brilliant Uncirculated standard – higher quality than other coins you’ll find in your pocket.

READ MORE: ‘Rare’ Paddington Bear 50p coin selling for a whopping £2,500 – is it worth it?

On the face of the coin, there is the recognisable illustration of Sherlock Holmes smoking a pipe.

Around this, the titles of popular Sherlock Holmes tales are written out.

The reverse design created by Stephen Raw features an instantly recognisable silhouette of Sherlock Holmes.

The eBay user “c.oakes”, uploaded the commemorative coin to the website along with several pictures of it.


However, the seller didn’t provide any further detail on the coin.

Although the mintage of the coin is not yet known, it is not necessarily rare or worth as much as the selling price would suggest.

Experts warn that coin enthusiasts should always check the mintage before purchasing a commemorative coin through the auction site, as frequently coins are uploaded to the auction website as “Rare” but carry little to no added value.

According to the Royal Mint, the Sherlock Holmes commemorative coin can be purchased through their website for only £10.

Therefore buyers could face a massive cost to add this piece to their collection.

So, why is the commemorative coin expensive despite its worth?

Sellers are well within their right to list items at whatever price they choose, therefore it’s down to the seller to take note when purchasing goods online.

In the coin publication Spend It? Save It? What Should You Do? the experts explained that sellers are well within their right to list coins at whatever price they choose.

The experts found that high price tags can make more affordable listings seem much more appealing, which could explain why some coins sell for as high as £10,000,000.

More often than not, the coins aren’t even worth that, so the buyer still ends up paying more than it is worth.

Nevertheless, they warned buyers, saying: “So remember – just because a coin is listed at a certain price that doesn’t mean it is worth it and just because something seems to have sold for a certain amount that doesn’t mean it actually did.”

Another 50p coin was recently listed on the auction site for a shocking £5,800.

Recently, the eBay user “sophieschoicex” uploaded a Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit coin with the asking price of £5,800. However, they revealed the 50p had a mint error which could explain the huge price tag.

The seller posted a selection of pictures of the Tale of Peter Rabbit 50p coin which was released in 2017.

The £5,800 asking price was justified as “sophieschoicex” said the coin was rare and had a unique printing error.

They said: “2017 Tale Of Peter Rabbit 50p Circulated Coin Mint Error on whisker – Very Rare.”

As well as the high asking price, those buying the coin would need to fork out an extra £1.06 to get the coin shipped by standard delivery.

Although the commemorative coin may be of interest to a number of people, this does not necessarily mean it is rare or worth as much as the price tag would suggest.

Related posts

UK royals give Boaty McBoatface polar ship its official name


Swiss church bells ring out after dark as court upholds nighttime chiming


Christ’s ‘crown of thorns’ tree may help in climate change fight: researchers


Leave a Comment